You know my first thought was that if I was a widower with two kids I definitely wouldn’t work in a job that dangerous but what are the chances that being an astronaut is actually safer than driving an hour long commute?
what are the chances that being an astronaut is actually safer than driving an hour long commute?
A trip to space is actually about 100,000 times more likely to lead to a fatality than a 20 mile car trip.
People really underestimate how dangerous space travel is.
(The math is in another comment below if you’re curious.)
You could die working in McDonald’s, at least this way he can support two kids on a single income.
I get it and I’m all for this mission.
But if I was a single dad I would never risk my life by going to the moon on a test flight.
I get your point
Holy shit the comments ITT
Man attempting to raise 2 daughters escapes to outer space
He fucked off further than anyone has ever fucked off before.
He just went out for a pack of smokes, he’ll be back any minute now…
Can he take my father? Was there a vote or lottery to send your bigoted parents to the moon.
outer space contains the best quality milk
What a fool, there are no cigarettes on the moon!
Don’t tell that to Elon. We still have a chance to send him away if he thinks he could somehow escape all the children he’s forcing women to have.
“Hey Elmo, the moon is made of drugs!”
I also choose this guy’s moon crater.
Yeah watched this live and man it was hard to work the rest of the day.
sorry i am too uneducated:
can someone explain what the meme is here?
Mods on this sub have no standards
Text + Picture = Meme
I think the meme-ness here is shaky, but I for one will allow it.
Absolute Gigachad!
Thousands of men do the same. Why is the guy who’s in a roller coaster amusement park ride the one who gets recognition?
Thousands of men do the same, every day, and they deserve recognition even if they neither want it or get it. Humanity can’t comprehend its own mass, so the occasional exceptional member becomes the focus of attention. This mission is plagued by the politics of American exceptionalism, “been there, done that”, and its own problems. Despite our advances and technology and Hollywood, still isn’t that easy to send a human around the moon.
Humanity can’t comprehend its own mass
If we can’t fathom the billions of miles between the stars, how could we possibly fathom billions of humans existing?
Because all single parents doing their best deserve recognition. We don’t know the other “thousands of men” or hundreds of milions of women names, but we know this one and we give him the recognition he deserves. It doesn’t mean all other doesn’t
Don’t worry, y’all, I will fix him 😪
We could have done the same goddamn thing without any people risking their lives strapped to bus atop a rocket.
We could have tested the safety of a manned mission without people on the manned mission? How in the hell do we do that?
We could have taken picture’s of the moon’s ass.
There is literally zero reason for us to put people in space when we can send drones to do it.
They’re practicing for the future manned landing
Which is fucking stupid and wasteful.
No. If we want to explore the universe and learn more about it, this is necessary. Go watch hank greens video about it. I don’t get why everyone’s malding about science being done.
It may be, but also…kinda cool?
Godforbid humanity just does something because it’s cool.
There are several reasons to put actual people in to space.
They might be reasons you think worth it, but they do exist.
We already have people in space on the ISS constantly, this manned moon mission is completely unnecessary
Indeed, no scientific studies could ever benefit from a 40% increase in data from test subjects.
Not to mention they aren’t even in the same environmental conditions, or doing the same activities, the data would be completely different (aside from the common baseline of space stuff) and therefore useless for comparison purposes.
I’m not sure why anyone would bother.
Look, i get why you might think it’s unnecessary, i don’t care enough to have an my own opinion on it’s cost/benefit analysis.
All i was saying is that reasons do exist.
You could get 40% more of the same data by increasing output on the ISS with no increased risk of death. The difference in environment between the ISS and the moon is worthless, instead of zero gravity they’re just in low gravity, which we can achieve without even going to the ISS, low orbit would do the trick with even lower risk. This is a publicity stunt to compensate for the US looking like a fucking joke, extra risk for no extra benefit beyond showing off.
All of what you said is reasonable at a glance, still it’s not relevant to my argument.
Reasons exist.
Whether or not the reasons are good is irrelevant to my original argument.
If you’re asking me whether or not i think the reasons are good, my answer is i don’t know and I’m not invested enough in the answer to go looking.
What i will do is put down my uneducated answers to your response.
You could get 40% more of the same data by increasing output on the ISS with no increased risk of death.
Increasing output of existing members is unlikely to be equivalent to data from entirely new test subjects.
40% more data on existing subjects isn’t the same as 40% additional data from new subjects.
For a more equal comparison you’d need to ship new people to the ISS and then your argument would only be true if there was zero risk of death in getting new people to the ISS.
The difference in environment between the ISS and the moon is worthless, instead of zero gravity they’re just in low gravity, which we can achieve without even going to the ISS, low orbit would do the trick with even lower risk.
That’s subjective but you could be right, i’d possibly argue that the combination of factors in space in addition to the low gravity would be different than a terrestrial equivalent, so a low gravity experiment in the ISS might be a better comparison.
I don’t know enough to be certain about any of that though.
This is a publicity stunt to compensate for the US looking like a fucking joke, extra risk for no extra benefit beyond showing off.
Possibly, i’d guess likely, but again i don’t know enough to have a reasonable opinion on this.
But it’s super cool.
They’re there to gather data on the moon’s surface and how being on a manned mission affects the human body.
We already have pictures of the dark side of the moon, so the intention this time was for the human eye to view it, since it gets much more detail anyway.
They’ve been testing the effects of low gravity on the human body in the ISS the whole time, they absolutely do not need to send people to the moon for that. Everything they’re doing right now could be done by an unmanned mission.
We already did that with Artemis I, this is a test flight for manned flights to build a base and explore further
you’re just cranky because your asshole is all cheezed up.
“Hey girls, I know mum died, but I’m going to risk my life flying a rocket to the moon so there’s a significant chance I won’t make it back and you two will have to figure shit out on your own. Bye, daddy’s gotta go, if I make it there I’ll name something after you or something. I left some cash on the table, don’t spend it all on pizza or meth, see ya! Well, maybe hahaha”
“Hey kids, I’m going to be gone for 2 weeks… Cause I’m going to the FUCKING MOON! Get dunked on nerds”
Yeah right. 'Cause he’s a stay-at-home dad all year round and just flies to the moon in between for a two-week workation.
I find this claim of “he raises his two daughters” very dubious. I bet he does not have the time to raise that much.
I worked for ESA, I had lunch with ‘just’ ISS astronauts. Their schedule is packed. They need to be in constant training and if they’re not, they have a lot of other duties. They’re barely home. Bet that’s even more true for astronauts flying to the moon.
I understand the PR, it’s good to have role models out there, I hope his daughters understand. But…meh.
Ya… That’s why he’s a bad parent.
We have absolutely no context on his personal life, just a couple news stories. Is he a bad parent because this is risky? Or a good parent because he’s being a role model for courage, or achieving your dreams, or something else.
We don’t know what the children value. We don’t know what kinds of talks they have had. I have no idea if his children asked him to not do it, or if they want him to fly around the moon. We don’t know what the contingency plan is if there’s an accident. I just don’t feel I know enough about their situation to say if he’s a bad parent or a good one.
I don’t even know how old his children are, I’m going to assume teens because he’s 50. Late teens early 20s is also possible. Either way old enough to have input and mature conversations.
You can easily find this information in a low level Google search.
That isn’t the point.
It doesn’t matter how old his kids are he’s their only dad.
I’m not saying he’s a bad person. I’m saying he took a risk he had no right to take.
The minutia and context is irrelevant.
Are you saying that he can’t have a conversation? If both his kids agree that he should go to the moon and he wants to go to the moon. He would still be a bad dad for going to the moon? I’m super confused by that line of logic.
I get why you’re being downvoted, but there’s definitely a wee bit of truth in there…
Somehow it’s heroic to abandon your kids who you raise on your own after their mother died to strap your ass on a big ass bomb, to go to a giant rock we already found to be inhospitable and useless 50 years ago. But thanks to the dick measuring contest between billionaires and dictators these days who sell their dumb ideas with fancy CGI promo videos which are total bullshit, we’re doing it all over again. It costs billions, while people can’t pay their rent, food, medical bills.
So I get the downvotes if you’re an American patriot who jerks off to the flag every day, because Americans don’t seem to care about child welfare with all those school shootings and known pedophiles voted Into office. Otherwise it’s just dumb to think this guy is somehow a hero for risking his kids losing both parents. Or that the crater thing makes up for it.
On the surface, I agree with you. As a parent myself, I would never go to the moon on a test flight like this.
As an American, though, I’d like to take a moment to politely tell you to go fuck yourself.
Wait! Let me explain. You have very good English, which suggests you’re probably from a well-developed country where English is a primary language. The level of hostility in your tone makes it unlikely you’re from a developing country. And even if you were, that wouldn’t put you in a better position to criticize.
If you are from a well-developed country, that means you have your own problems, don’t you?
Talk about the pot calling the kettle black.
If you don’t like America, then get off Lemmy. Because guess what? Lemmy was largely developed by an American. Yes, I know it involved collaboration with developers from other countries, but the primary origin is still American.
Ignoring all your weird patronization of the global south…
If you don’t like America, then get off Lemmy. Because guess what? Lemmy was largely developed by an American. Yes, I know it involved collaboration with developers from other countries, but the primary origin is still American.
No idea if the main developer, comrade dessalines, is American, but they have a Che Guevara profile pic.
Here’s a snippet from the US atrocities section of their essays repo:
“If there is a country that has committed unspeakable atrocities in the world, it is the United States of America. They don’t care for human beings.” - Nelson Mandela
Two of the other original devs are Nutomic and SleeplessOne1917. Nutomic has a Fidel Castro pfp, and SleeplessOne1917 uses the year of the October revolution in their username. Safe to say the devs of Lemmy do not like America. They also admin lemmygrad.ml
Might want to check your assumptions (and western chauvinism)
If you
don’tlike America, then get off Lemmy. Because guess what? Lemmy was largely developed byan Americanbased communist revolutionaries. Yes, I know it involved collaboration with developers fromother countriesthe great satan, but the primary origin is stillAmericanMarxist-Leninist.FTFY!
I couldn’t care less where the other devs are from or their ideological/political associations. All of that is entirely irrelevant.
What is relevant however is exactly what you didn’t want to talk about. For example, what country you’re from. Which tells me pretty much everything I need to know. Just put a sock in your mouth and shut up.
Also not taking the bullshit communist bait.
You didn’t even notice that was someone else replying to you. Also most Lemmy instances are hosted in Europe. So if you prefer a mostly American platform, go to reddit or X. Also, Lemmy is generally political left, including far left. And by left I don’t mean American left, because what you consider left politically is considered right by the rest of the world where as your right is to the rest alt right or right wing extremism, going as far as fascism.
The fact that I’m anti American is because of all the wars they started, the warcrimes and crimes against humanity they committed and are still committing, the insane level of self centeredness and narcissistic behavior by most Americans and maybe the fact they started World War 3 because they voted a known criminal and child sex abusing dictator into office for a second time. While it’s own people are starving and dying of gun violence, including by federal agents, and easy but too expensive treatments for illnesses, while having barely any rights causing them to become homeless, easily fired or paid far under minimum wage which already is way too low for current living standards.
But before the whole Trump thing, most of the world already hated the US. For most it was like “better try to keep them as friends rather than enemies” but no one liked those warmongering dumbfucks who only care about themselves. And for good reason, look what it brought us all.
So if you’re American I can understand that the welfare of your kid(s) isn’t the highest priority and a trip to the moon might be cooler than raising them (like like owning guns is cooler than removing the risk of your kid being shot and killed at school).
I don’t have kids, but if I did I wouldn’t take risks like this, especially not when they already lost their mother. The foster care system is fucked, almost everywhere. Especially in the US. If I were to have kids, I would take my responsibility as a father.
Then there’s still the thing about where I’m from. I don’t see how that is relevant. But you assume all primary English speaking countries are developed, yet there are also third world countries where english is one of their main, or it’s only language. Like the US (now legally it’s only language thanks to Trump), Botswana, Liberia, Nigeria, etc. And yes, with the current wealth inequality, corruption, general survival chance and general quality of life of the average US population, it also classifies as a third world country. I mean, they still have legal slavery. But you’re not the only American assuming all English speaking countries are developed.
I am from a developed country and we do have issues, as every country does. Non of our national issues come even close to the issues the US has, or the US is causing to us. And English isn’t one of our primary languages, our official languages are Dutch and Frisian but we are educated, as contrary to the US, attending school is mandatory by law. I’ve had English, German and French in school for 13 years next to Dutch. Currently I’m learning Norwegian as my partner is from there. But foreign languages are hard for me, I’m a beta person so I’m excelling in math and science. I’m also dyslexic so I keep making mistakes.
But we’re moving away from the main subject here. You agree with me you won’t risk your kids losing their farther by doing this. But then you say I can go fuck myself because you’re American. Why though, I don’t understand. Because you’re proud the US is going back to the moon? You know your tax money is paying for this bullshit right?
There’s a reason we didn’t go back there for 50 years.
Whatever we can achieve on the moon like farming water ice can be done better with robots, either autonomous or remote controlled (because the moon distance has barely any latency), as the entire infrastructure for humans is overly complex, expensive and dangerous and causes the eventual process to include the human error factor. But rationality is gone when corporate/billionaire/dictator greed comes into the equation.
As an American
Are you aware that every non-US American immediately rolls their eyes and won’t take anything else coming out of your mouth serious, when you say something like that?
If you don’t like America, then get off Lemmy. Because guess what? Lemmy was largely developed by an American.
Stock exchange was invented by the Dutch. If you don’t like the Dutch, would you sell all your stocks if you had them? What a bullshit argument. “Oh I don’t want that medication because it was invented by a French person”. Grow up. Your entire country is based on European countries, it’s heritage, culture and inventions, and exists mainly due to genocide of the native Americans and slavery which boosted its economy.
(did some grammatical and typo edits)
You do realize that multiple other genocides have happened since the American massacre of Native Americans?
There isn’t a single country on this planet that doesn’t have black smears all over its history.
And if a country’s history isn’t quite as bad as America’s, its people are just as shitty as they are everywhere else. Humans are terrible, vile, disgusting creatures that trample over everything they touch.
It’s easy to blame America, and as much as I truly dislike our government and our current president, I still love my country, its people, and living here.
Moreover, I couldn’t care less how much credibility I have in the comment section of a Lemmy post.
If you think you can stand on your laurels because you’re not American, once again, you can quietly go fuck yourself.
And the beautiful thing is, as an American, I get to say that to whoever the hell I want.
Interstellar vibes
true
Downvoted for being right, by butthurt americans desperately trying to convince themselves that the US isn’t a complete fucking joke
Can you blame uneducated brainwashed narcissistic fascists? Their feelings got hurt. Downvoting is the patriotic thing to do, some even go as far as a dillusional rant as a comment.
Not to be a dick…but imagine a mother putting her two kids who have already lost their dad at a serious risk of becoming orphans
Why did you have to switch the genders to make this absurd point?
Because mothers get vilified for things but when fathers do it it’s heroic.
You’re not wrong. Male CEOs do not get asked how they balance work with fatherhood.
I don’t think mother astronauts get vilified. The first one did back in the 70s, but mothers are constantly going to space. Granted they weren’t single parents.
Like I get what you’re talking about, and you’re not wrong. It’s just a weird topic to inject into this post.
I don’t think it’s that likely surely it’s less risky than driving?
It is massively dangerous.
As of April 2026, a total of 791 people have flown into space and 19 of them have died in related incidents. This sets the current statistical fatality rate at 2.4 percent.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_spaceflight-related_accidents_and_incidents
Ahhhh I see thanks
Or to look at it from a different angle, 5 out of the 413 total manned space flights have ended in fatalities, or 1.21%.
Auto travel in the US has a fatality rate around 1 death per 100 million driven miles. Assuming an average trip of 20 miles, that’s 1 death per 5 million car trips, or 0.00002%.
So, roughly 10,000 (EDIT: actually 100,000, missed a zero!) times more dangerous than driving.
What do the numbers look like if we assume the average trip is from the earth to the moon and back?
Are you asking to change the definition of a car trip to the ~500,000 miles it takes to get to the moon and back?
In that case, rate of fatality is around 1 in 200 “driving to the moon and back” trips. 0.5% chance. So taking the rocketship is still significantly more dangerous.
More realistically, 500,000 miles is roughly a lifetime of driving. So these astronauts are being exposed in a single trip to a fatality risk equivalent of 2+ lifetimes of driving.
Thanks for satiating my curiosity.
100,000 actually.
Good catch! Lost track of my zeros
No, definitely not. Spaceflight is still very dangerous.
deleted by creator















